Pie Party Gluten Free Lemon Meringue Pie

The very first lemon meringue pie that our oldest daughter ate was prepared by her lemon-loving grandmother.  In their house, if something wasn’t made with mayonnaise, it was at least prepared with lemon.  Oh. Wait.  Isn’t there lemon in mayonnaise?  That would be two for the price of one.

My mother-in-law is nothing if not clever.  She grew up in California’s central valley on a small farm-ish where they had their own chickens, fruit trees, gardens and perhaps I am imagining it, a cow.  She learned the art of chicken plucking early on and was kind enough to never explain it in full detail.  She told us how they made mayonnaise because store-bought was not only too expensive but tasteless.  Lemons dropped from their orchard trees like snow does in some other parts of the country, so they used them in everything.  Lemon meringue was a frequent pie of the week at their house.

That day my daughter ate her first lemon pie, she carried on tradition.  The child, in a high chair and yet to have uttered her first word,  was given a lemon wedge to gnaw on while dinner was being prepared and brought to the table.  Before I knew it my little child was two-fisting lemon wedges into her mouth faster than I’d eat M&Ms.  Aghast, I tried to remove them from her clenched fists without success.   Apparently that lemon-loving addiction was more than a habit – it might be in the genes.

And then in the middle of everyone cooing over how adorable the child was completely smeared with lemon, she uttered her first words aloud.  A car horn blared in the neighborhood cutting through the quiet like a sling shot of thunder.  With her mouth full, she looked up and yelled out only a word a parent could appreciate – if only they were not in the company of two generations of grandparents.  Shit was what she yelled.  Just shit.  Try that through a mouth of lemon and there is  bound to be one elderly person, (think great-grandmother) a bit hard of hearing, who will turn to the child and ask:  “What?”   And of course said child will yell out once again – “SHIT!” while spitting lemon along with the expletive.

Some snickered.  One turned beet red (me) and the grandparents snorted with glee while the great-grandmother looked like she was going to have  a heart attack and gave us scathing looks.

And from that day four hundred years back, although lemon meringue pie is still a favorite around here, no one can eat a slice without snickering about that day when the child uttered her first word.

Happy Pie Party Day.  And here’s to lemon pie.

For easy as 3-2-1 pie crust go here.

And for the best (Dorie Greenspan) lemon cream you will want to visit here.  The first time I made the lemon cream, I used my Waring Blender and broke it.  Happily, the food processor did the job this time with little effort.  This is the lemon filling you want in this pie.  You will never make anything else again after tasting this.  I promise.

Pie Party Lemon Meringue Pie
Recipe type: dessert
  • one GF pie crust, blind baked (see post for link)
  • one batch of lemon cream (see post for link)
  • 4 large egg whites, room temperature
  • pinch of cream of tartar
  • pinch of salt
  • ¾ cup superfine sugar
  • ½ teaspoon pure vanilla
  1. Preheat oven to 350
  2. Bake pie crust according to directions. Spoon in lemon cream.
  3. In a large bowl of a stand mixer, beat whites with cream of tartar and salt until frothy. Start adding in sugar slowly as the mixer whips the whites. Whip until sturdy and glossy peaks form.
  4. Spoon meringue over lemon cream to the edges of the pie crust. Bake at 350 for about 10 minutes or just until the meringue is beginning to brown. Cool on a rack. Refrigerate until cream is set, about two hours.



  1. That is so awesome. The story, the pie, everything. I can’t believe I’ve never made lemon meringue pie. I’ve made that lemon cream several times, but it’s never ended up in a pie! Great idea!

    • GlutenFreeCanteen says:

      I love that lemon cream, too! Pie is just one of its homes – love it with fruit, in a tart, from the container….

  2. Your story is absolutely hilarious! I’m sitting here laughing 😀
    And the pie looks gorgeous! I love how tall the meringue is!

  3. That story is wonderful 🙂 Can never predict what a kid will do next! You only had to say the word lemon (and the word pie helped too!) to have my complete attention, love the stuff, i think you are right there might well be a genetic basis to it 🙂 That filling sounds especially divine, recipe saved!

  4. Your story sent me laughing!!! I am so happy to have stumbled upon your blog!! The pie is awesome. Loved your blog and your photography!! Do visit mine if you love Asian (especially Indian) food. Shall come back again very soon!

  5. That story is just hysterically funny! I am looking forward to making the lemon-meringue pie, but I’ll probably be snickering the whole time. Thank you so much … for the story AND the recipe!


  1. […] stumbled across this post by Gluten Free Canteen and was immediately encouraged; I have made recipes off this blog before […]